Horizontal Rule

Kleyn and Aleksandrovich v Russia

3 May 2012

Forum: European Court of Human Rights
ERRC role: Representative
Status: Implementation

The case concerns the death in 2002 of Fatsima Aleksandrovich after she jumped out of a second-floor window in a police station where she was being held on suspicion of pick-pocketing.

Ms Aleksandrovich was arrested on a bus in Pskov and taken to the local police station for questioning. About two and half hours later her unconscious body was found in the police station courtyard. She was taken to hospital in a coma and died four days later. The autopsy report concluded that she had died of cerebral trauma and numerous other injuries to her body. The report also noted scratches on her left wrist and right knee.

According to the Government, Ms Aleksandrovich had jumped from a toilet window in order to escape.

Relying in particular on Article 2 (right to life), the applicants alleged that Ms Aleksandrovich had died as a result of ill-treatment in police custody and that her unconscious body had been placed in the police courtyard to make it look like she had tried to escape from the toilet window.

The Court reiterated that anyone held in custody was particularly vulnerable and the authorities were therefore obliged to account for the way in which they were treated. In this case, there was no serious evidence to support the allegation that anyone had intentionally taken Ms Aleksandrovich's life. There had therefore been no violation of the substantive limb of Article 2.

The Court went on to find that due to an inadequate legal framework and failure to ensure the effective participation of Ms Aleksandrovich's next of kin in any form of criminal proceedings, the Russian authorities had not taken all reasonable steps to determine the circumstances in which she had died.

The Court also pointed out that no criminal investigation into Ms Aleksandrovich's death had ever been launched. The authorities refused to open an investigation on at least four occasions and the domestic courts even admitted that, on that account, her partner's access to justice had been breached.  There was therefore a breach of the procedural limb of Article 2.

Case documents:

  • Judgment of the case of Kleyn and Aleksandrovich v Russia (in English)
  • ERRC application to the European Court of Human Rights

Horizontal Rule

ERRC submission to UN HRC on Hungary (February 2018)

14 February 2018

Written Comments of the European Roma Rights Centre concerning Hungary to the UN Human Rights Committee for consideration at its 122nd session (12 Narch - 6 April 2018).

more ...

horizontal rule

The Fragility of Professional Competence: A Preliminary Account of Child Protection Practice with Romani and Traveller Children in England

24 January 2018

Romani and Traveller children in England are much more likely to be taken into state care than the majority population, and the numbers are rising. Between 2009 and 2016 the number of Irish Travellers in care has risen by 400% and the number of Romani children has risen 933%. The increases are not consistent with national trends, and when compared to population data, suggest that Romani and Traveller children living in the UK could be 3 times more likely be taken into public care than any other child. 

more ...

horizontal rule

Families Divided: Romani and Egyptian Children in Albanian Institutions

21 November 2017

There’s a high percentage of Romani and Egyptian children in children’s homes in Albania – a disproportionate number. These children are often put into institutions because of poverty, and then find it impossible ever to return to their families. Because of centuries of discrimination Roma and Egyptians in Albania are less likely to live in adequate housing, less likely to be employed and more likely to feel the effects of extreme poverty.

more ...

horizontal rule